black locust vs honey locust

Poolie Author

2 min read

·

26-12-2024

6

0

Share

Black Locust vs. Honey Locust: Two Thorny Trees with Distinct Differences

Black locust and honey locust trees, both members of the Robinia genus, are often confused due to their similar names and thorny nature. However, these trees possess distinct characteristics that set them apart in terms of appearance, growth habits, and uses. Understanding these differences is crucial for proper identification and informed planting decisions.

Appearance and Identification:

Growth Habits and Habitat:

Black locust is a fast-growing tree, known for its nitrogen-fixing abilities, enriching the soil. It prefers full sun and well-drained soil but is surprisingly adaptable to various soil conditions. It is native to the eastern United States and is often found in open woods, pastures, and along roadsides.

Honey locust, also a fast-growing tree, is more tolerant of drought and poor soil conditions compared to black locust. Its tolerance to urban conditions makes it a popular choice for landscaping. While native to the central and eastern United States, it’s been widely planted across the country. It is more widely distributed geographically.

Uses and Considerations:

Both species have valuable uses:

• Black Locust: The wood is extremely durable and rot-resistant, making it ideal for fence posts, railroad ties, and furniture. It's also a valuable source of nectar for honeybees. However, it can be invasive in some areas.

• Honey Locust: The wood is less durable than black locust but still finds use in construction and landscaping. Thornless cultivars are readily available and preferred for ornamental planting. The seeds of honey locust were historically used as food by Native Americans.

Distinguishing them in the field: The most reliable way to distinguish between the two is by examining the thorns and leaves closely. Black locust has single, stout thorns at the leaf bases, while honey locust boasts branched, often clustered thorns on the branches and trunk. The leaf structure also differs significantly, with black locust having fewer, larger leaflets arranged simply and honey locust exhibiting many smaller leaflets in a bipinnate arrangement.

Conclusion:

While both black locust and honey locust share some similarities, their differences in thorns, leaves, and growth habits are significant. By carefully observing these characteristics, you can accurately identify these trees and appreciate their unique contributions to the landscape and various industries. Choosing the right tree for your needs will depend on factors such as desired size, soil conditions, and intended use. Consider the pros and cons of each species before planting.